My
TOEFL students REALLY struggled with inference in Wednesdays lesson so I
gave them a quick worksheet with simple sentences and then asked them
to infer.
Students: To stay fit. Because you are late. To get away from someone etc.
Me: Is the man working out?
Students: No, he has a lunch box.
Me: Why would he run with a lunch box?
Students: He needs to give it to someone
Me: Whom might he need to give it to?
My students had NO idea. I even had a volunteer come to the front of the class and stand there while I pointed at his general groin area. They were clueless! Once I explained it they all understood, but I was amazed no one got it.
I talked to my boss and a few other people and they got it right away... I wonder why they had so much trouble.
Do you get it?
- Example: "Oh honey you don't have to get be anything for my birthday, just being with you is enough. I am going to go to the store now. I hope that my purse doesn't fall apart on the way there. It is so old!"
- Inference: The person would like a purse for their birthday.
- Example: An older man is running behind a school bus waving a child's lunch box in the air
Students: To stay fit. Because you are late. To get away from someone etc.
Me: Is the man working out?
Students: No, he has a lunch box.
Me: Why would he run with a lunch box?
Students: He needs to give it to someone
Me: Whom might he need to give it to?
- Inference: The man's child is on the bus and has forgotten his lunch.
My students had NO idea. I even had a volunteer come to the front of the class and stand there while I pointed at his general groin area. They were clueless! Once I explained it they all understood, but I was amazed no one got it.
I talked to my boss and a few other people and they got it right away... I wonder why they had so much trouble.
Do you get it?
jeez, i'm always suffering the same. i keep telling my fellow teachers that it's not about ELL, it's about IQ level!!!
ReplyDeletegod be with u
So many different things to focus on when teaching!
Delete